"It was a cool feeling," Romano tells PEOPLE. "We weren't admitting to ourselves, 'I'm a big sitcom star, and you're a big sitcom star,' but we understood this is kind of unique and cool"

That’s the premise of Netflix’s No Good Deed, an eight-part series that is billed as a comedy and boasts the 1990s sitcom nostalgia combo of Ray Romano and Lisa Kudrow. As it turns out, the show is more of an uneven hybrid of suburban whodunnit and semi-sincere relationship drama.